Leave a Message
By providing your contact information to Rainmaker Collective, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Rainmaker Collective's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Rainmaker Collective in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Rainmaker Collective at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Brick-and-ivory-sided home with dark-framed windows, a closed glass back door and a concrete terrace edged by autumn oakleaf hydrangea.

Moline Rebuilt Captain's Table After the 2018 Fire. This Summer It Let Go, and the Old Name Came Back.

November 12, 2026

In the late 1990s, Jason and Amy Stumphy were coworkers at a riverfront restaurant at 4801 River Drive in Moline. They met there, later held their wedding reception there, and stayed on staff until 2004, according to the Geneseo Current. Two decades later, they own the building and are putting a familiar name on it: Stumphy's Captain's Table.

The building had been sitting empty since Catfish Charlie's closed in 2024, and the reason goes back to the fire. For most of the past eight years, the City of Moline was more than the landlord on River Drive. It was the restaurant's lender. The old name could only come back after the council voted this July to end that arrangement.

A building that's newer than its name

The name goes back to the 1970s, and KWQC reported that the original Captain's Table ran for more than 50 years. The building is much younger. On Jan. 15, 2018, the restaurant burned during renovations. It was rebuilt, reopened as Captain's Table, and later rebranded as Catfish Charlie's. Amy Stumphy told KWQC that the Catfish Charlie's name lasted less than a year, even though many people still call the place by it.

Here's the site's history in order:

  • 1970s: Captain's Table opens at 4801 River Drive, beside the city's Marquis Harbor marina.
  • Late 1990s to 2004: Jason and Amy Stumphy work there, meet there and hold their wedding reception there.
  • Jan. 15, 2018: Fire destroys the building during renovations.
  • July 2018: The city discusses a 20-year lease to rebuild.
  • After the rebuild: The restaurant reopens as Captain's Table, then becomes Catfish Charlie's.
  • 2024: The restaurant closes.
  • July 2026: The council votes to end the lease and sell the restaurant lot.
  • Fall 2026: The Stumphys move their restaurant from outside Geneseo to River Drive under the old name.

How the city ended up paying for a riverfront kitchen

The city owned the land, so after the fire the decision about what to build fell to City Hall. In July 2018, then-City Administrator Doug Maxeiner told KWQC the city was facing a "chicken and the egg" question. It wanted a long-term tenant signed before it spent money building a restaurant.

The draft lease shows how deeply the city was involved. An architect estimated the new building at $1.6 million. Insurance was expected to cover just under $1 million. The city would pay the rest up front, and the tenant would repay it over time.

Draft lease terms, July 2018 Amount
Base rent $34,000 a year, plus a share of sales above $1.5 million
Added rent to repay construction costs insurance didn't cover $56,288 a year
Fixed yearly rent, before any sales share $90,288
Rent before the fire About $50,000 to $55,000 a year
Marina rent 10 percent of dockage fees

The design promised glass walls facing the river and a banquet hall. The city hoped to have it built by July 2019. The lease that eventually took effect went further than the draft. A council memo from this summer says the amended lease extended city loans to the operator in two forms: an equipment loan with a note, and construction financing repaid as "additional rent."

For as long as that lease stood, the building, the city's loans and the marina next door were all tied to one agreement, so a new operator couldn't simply take over the keys.

The July votes that cleared the way

On July 7, 2026, the Moline City Council took up a special ordinance covering "Catfish Charlie's and Marquis Harbor Marina." That night the council gave initial approval to an exchange and purchase-sale agreement with the operator's company, Pretasky Roach Properties, LLC, and to ending the amended lease at 4801 River Drive. Chris Parr, the city's chief economic development officer, told the council the agreement would convey real and personal property, settle outstanding debts between the two parties, and end the lease. The motion passed unanimously.

The council packet spells out the terms. The city receives $350,000 for the restaurant lot, "due upon subsequent third-party sale." The equipment loan and the additional-rent obligation are canceled, and the city takes ownership of the marina improvements, which the agreement values at the same amount. KWQC reported that the city keeps ownership of Marquis Harbor and will continue to lease it.

The same meeting fixed a small detail that would otherwise have held up a sale. The building encroaches on city right-of-way along River Drive to the south, covering 524 square feet. The council voted to vacate that strip and add it to the parcel's legal description "to support the sale of the Parcel to a third-party." On July 21, the council gave final approval to both measures, Special Ordinance 4001-2026 and Ordinance 3038-2026, on a 7-0 consent vote.

After that, the property could change hands. KWQC reported that the Stumphys saw their chance when the city decided to sell.

What the couple who met there are putting back

The Stumphys arrive with a working restaurant. They had spent several months running Stumphy's Restaurant & Bar at Sugar Maple Golf Club outside Geneseo, and they served a farewell buffet there on Sunday, Sept. 27. Jason has worked in restaurant kitchens for 30 years, KWQC reported. The move gives them far more room. The Geneseo Current reported seating for about 300 people inside and 75 on the patio, plus a larger kitchen.

About 60 percent of the Geneseo menu is coming along. Amy Stumphy told KWQC that menu was already close to the old Captain's Table menu, and the River Drive kitchen will add more of the Captain's favorites. The planned menu includes:

  • From the original kitchen: the Captain's clam chowder, and Stumphy's garlic salad dressing, which Amy Stumphy says uses the original Captain's Table recipe
  • Steaks and seafood: several filet and sirloin cuts, including the "chubby" sirloin; a 24-ounce cold-water lobster tail, also offered as a 12-ounce half to add to any steak; crab-stuffed whitefish; and mango chutney pecan-crusted salmon
  • Catfish: a full pound, served fried, broiled or Cajun broiled
  • Lunch and starters: escargot with blue cheese and garlic butter, and homemade chicken salad on honey wheat bread
  • Made in-house: every soup and sauce, plus hand-breaded pork tenderloins and other fried entrees

KWQC reported that food and drink prices start around $6, alongside a wine list and handcrafted cocktails. Amy Stumphy described the goal this way:

"I just want everyone to feel like this is a place that they can come, and spend $15 on a meal or on up. But I don't want anyone to feel excluded."

The outdoor plans also lean on the location. The owners plan outdoor bands on Sundays from 4 to 8 p.m., with an outdoor bar and outdoor food service. Boaters can reach the restaurant through the marina's slips and gas dock. Amy Stumphy said she plans to work with Metro in the spring to see whether the restaurant could become a water taxi stop the following year, which would likely mean modifying the dock.

Planning a visit this winter

The Geneseo Current listed expected winter hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday and 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Sunday, closed Mondays. Amy Stumphy told KWQC that hours may run longer in summer. The restaurant posts updates on its Facebook page, Stumphy's Captain's Table, and planned to launch a website in early November.

A staff of 18 is moving from Geneseo, and the owners expect to hire up to 50 more people as the Moline restaurant grows. New hires go through two full weeks of training, Amy Stumphy told KWQC.

The riverfront spot where people held birthday parties and family celebrations for decades is in private hands again. The city still owns the harbor beside it.

At Rainmaker Collective, we follow stories like this one along River Drive and across the Quad Cities, from who owns a riverfront parcel to what the council decided about it. If you'd like to hear how changes like this are shaping the stretch of Moline you call home, contact us. We're glad to talk it through over a bowl of chowder.

Follow Us On Instagram